A player can arrive with an impressive reputation and fail to adapt, while another can come with question marks over his price, age, previous form or suitability for a new league before eventually becoming a club legend.
Some of football’s greatest transfer decisions initially looked like gambles and quite risky.
Clubs had to take significant financial or sporting risks, trust their recruitment departments and sometimes ignore widespread doubts from supporters and the media.
In this article, Sporting Tribune spotlights the 10 risky football transfers at the time but ultimately paid off.
Virgil van Dijk – Southampton to Liverpool
When Virgil van Dijk moved from Southampton to Liverpool in January 2018, the £75 million fee made him the world’s most expensive defender.
The price immediately created enormous expectations.
ALSO READ: 10 players who made iconic returns to their former clubs
Liverpool had already been criticised for their defensive problems, while spending such a huge amount on a centre-back was considered a major gamble.
Van Dijk became a key figure in Liverpool’s Champions League triumph in 2019 and Premier League title-winning campaign in 2019/20. Liverpool later described him as one of the world’s best defenders, while his trophy collection continued to grow.
Mohamed Salah – Roma to Liverpool
Liverpool’s decision to pay around £37 million for Mohamed Salah in 2017 came with a major question attached: could the Egyptian succeed in England after struggling for regular football at Chelsea?
Salah had already rebuilt his reputation in Italy with Fiorentina and Roma, but there was no guarantee that his second Premier League opportunity would be different.
The gamble paid off almost immediately.
He scored 44 goals in 52 appearances during his first Liverpool season, including 32 Premier League goals.
The player Chelsea had struggled to accommodate became one of Liverpool’s defining stars.
Luka Modrić – Tottenham Hotspur to Real Madrid
When Luka Modrić joined Real Madrid in 2012, the move was not universally celebrated.
The Croatian midfielder faced questions over whether his relatively small frame and Premier League style would translate successfully into Madrid’s demanding midfield.
He eventually became one of the greatest midfielders in the club’s history.
Modrić won six European Cups with Real Madrid, multiple La Liga titles and the 2018 Ballon d’Or. By the end of his Madrid career, the club had described him as a legend and its most decorated player by number of trophies.
Eric Cantona – Leeds United to Manchester United
The Eric Cantona transfer remains one of the most influential bargains in English football history.
Manchester United signed the French forward from Leeds United in November 1992 for a relatively modest fee.
At the time, Cantona was already a talented player, but his career had been complicated by disciplinary issues and inconsistent spells in France and England.
Cantona became the creative focal point of Sir Alex Ferguson’s attack and helped Manchester United win four Premier League titles in five seasons.
Didier Drogba – Marseille to Chelsea
When Chelsea paid a club-record fee for Didier Drogba in 2004, the Ivorian was not yet the global superstar he would become.
He had impressed at Marseille, particularly in European competition, but moving to the Premier League and carrying the expectations of a major transfer represented a significant challenge.
Chelsea’s own historical account notes that Drogba was a promising striker who was relatively unknown in England despite his performances for Marseille.
Drogba scored 164 goals in 381 appearances across two Chelsea spells, won four Premier League titles and played a decisive role in Chelsea’s first Champions League triumph.
Arjen Robben – Real Madrid to Bayern Munich
When Arjen Robben left Real Madrid for Bayern Munich in 2009, there were understandable doubts.
The Dutch winger had suffered repeated injury problems and was being moved on by one of Europe’s biggest clubs.
Robben became one of the defining players of the club’s modern era, forming a famous partnership with Franck Ribéry and scoring the winning goal in the 2013 Champions League final.
Dennis Bergkamp – Inter Milan to Arsenal
Dennis Bergkamp arrived at Arsenal in 1995 after a difficult period at Inter Milan.
The Dutch forward had struggled to establish himself in Italy, creating doubts over whether he could adapt to English football.
Arsenal took the gamble. Bergkamp became a cornerstone of Arsène Wenger’s revolution and one of the most technically gifted players in Premier League history.
His arrival also helped change perceptions of the type of attacking football Arsenal could play.
N’Golo Kanté – Caen to Leicester City
Leicester City’s recruitment of N’Golo Kanté did not initially attract the same attention as the club’s more expensive signings.
Kanté had impressed in France and with Leicester’s scouting department, but he was joining a Premier League side that had narrowly avoided relegation the previous season.
The gamble proved extraordinary. Kanté became central to Leicester’s remarkable 2015/16 Premier League title and then moved to Chelsea, where he won another Premier League title and the Champions League.
Roberto Firmino – Hoffenheim to Liverpool
When Liverpool signed Roberto Firmino from Hoffenheim in 2015, there was uncertainty about how the Brazilian would fit into English football.
He had been productive in Germany but was not a household name among Premier League supporters.
Under Jürgen Klopp, Firmino’s role evolved.
Rather than functioning as a conventional striker, he became the central link in Liverpool’s attack, dropping into midfield and creating space for Mohamed Salah and Sadio Mané.
The result was one of the most effective attacking partnerships of the modern Premier League era.
Cristiano Ronaldo – Sporting CP to Manchester United
Manchester United’s decision to sign Cristiano Ronaldo from Sporting CP in 2003 was a bet on potential.
Ronaldo was a talented teenager, but he had never played senior football in one of Europe’s major leagues.
The transfer was initially about developing a gifted young winger.
What followed exceeded almost every expectation.
Ronaldo developed into one of the greatest players in football history, winning multiple Premier League titles, the Champions League and the Ballon d’Or before moving to Real Madrid.
