‘Champions must go up’: Why Lokomotive Leipzig are stuck in Germany’s fourth tier

Femi Akinyemi

Djamal Ziane has lifted the same trophy three times, but the Lokomotive Leipzig captain has never been able to celebrate it with promotion.

Lok Leipzig won the Regionalliga Nordost title again in 2026, two years after their previous success and six years after their first. Yet, as happened in 2020 and 2025, the title did not guarantee a place in Germany’s 3. Liga.

Instead, Leipzig had to play Würzburger Kickers, the Regionalliga Bayern champions, for the final promotion place.

Ziane scored in the second leg in Würzburg, but the Kickers won 2-1 to complete a 3-1 aggregate victory and secure promotion.

For Leipzig, it was another season ending with a title but no promotion.

“It’s the worst thing, injury aside, that you can experience as a footballer. Catastrophe doesn’t cut it. It doesn’t make any sense. If they really wanted to change it, they could do it tomorrow,” Ziane said.

That frustration has spread beyond Leipzig.

Across German football, clubs and supporters have been campaigning for a change to the promotion system, with the slogan “Meister müssen aufsteigen!”, “Champions must go up!”

Five leagues, four places

The Regionalliga is the fourth level of German football, below the Bundesliga, 2. Bundesliga and 3. Liga.

There are five divisions: North, West, Southwest, Northeast and Bavaria.

Each produces a league winner, but only four clubs can be promoted to the 3. Liga.

The West and Southwest champions have fixed automatic promotion places. The other two promotion places are shared among the North, Northeast and Bavaria divisions under a rotation system, with the remaining two champions meeting in a play-off.

So every season, one regional champion is left without an automatic route to the third tier.

For players and clubs who have spent months trying to win their division, that can mean the season comes down to two more matches.

Lok Leipzig know the feeling better than most.

ALSO READ: Klopp gets first win as Germany coach

They also came close to promotion in 2020, when two draws against SC Verl left them behind on the away-goals rule then in use. In 2025, they lost to TSV Havelse in the promotion play-offs.

Then came 2026 and another title, followed by another play-off.

Why the Northeast wants change

The Regionalliga Nordost covers the territory of the former East Germany, and clubs from the region have repeatedly found themselves having to fight for the final promotion place.

Dynamo Berlin missed out in 2022 after winning the division. Energie Cottbus suffered the same fate in 2023.

For clubs in the Northeast, the debate is also linked to the wider economic differences between eastern and western Germany.

Clubs in the western regions generally operate in larger markets, with bigger populations and stronger commercial bases.

But attendance has also become part of the argument.

Lok Leipzig have a substantial following for a fourth-tier club, while matches against city rivals Chemie Leipzig have drawn crowds well above the league average.

Toni Wachsmuth, Lok Leipzig’s chief executive, has argued that crowds, tradition and history do not count towards promotion despite their importance to a club.

“You don’t get any points for tradition, crowds and history,” he said.

The frustration has helped turn a regional complaint into a national debate.

The compass model

The main proposal for change is known as the compass model.

Instead of five Regionalliga divisions, there would be four, with 20 clubs in each. The composition of the divisions would be reassessed each season according to geography and travel distances.

The four league winners would then all receive direct promotion to the 3. Liga.

A DFB working group backed a four-division structure in March and put forward the compass model and another regions-based proposal for consideration.

The compass model subsequently received the largest share of votes in consultations among clubs, but it did not secure agreement in all five regions.

That left the reform process unresolved.

Clubs join the campaign

The campaign has attracted support well beyond the Northeast.

More than 80 clubs have backed the call for reform, while Bundesliga clubs have also spoken in favour of giving every regional champion a direct route to the 3. Liga.

Union Berlin president Dirk Zingler has criticised the current system, while Borussia Dortmund president Hans-Joachim Watzke has also backed the principle that league winners should be promoted.

Marco Rose, who has a long association with Lok Leipzig as a former player and coach, has also spoken in support of the clubs and their supporters.

The issue has increasingly appeared in the stands as well.

Lok Leipzig supporters protested by throwing plastic trophies onto the pitch, highlighting the frustration of winning titles without securing promotion.

Other supporters across Germany have displayed banners calling for the system to be changed.

Reform still faces resistance

Not every regional association has embraced the proposed changes.

Some clubs and officials have raised concerns over travel, finances and the way the new divisions would be formed.

The Regionalliga Südwest, for example, has questioned whether replacing the existing structure with a new system would create enough benefits to justify the disruption.

Bavarian clubs have also expressed reservations about giving up the existing Regionalliga Bayern structure.

That explains why a proposal that appears simple from the outside has proved difficult to implement.

The DFB has been working on the issue since 2025, with representatives from the five Regionalliga divisions involved in the reform process.

In September, however, the DFB announced that the process had reached the point where its highest decision-making body would be asked to vote on a possible change.

December decision

The DFB has scheduled an extraordinary Bundestag for December 18, 2026.

The proposed reform would reduce the number of Regionalliga divisions from five to four, with each division containing 20 teams. Clubs would be grouped according to geographical considerations, with the DFB taking responsibility for the competition.

If approved, the 2027-28 season would be used as a qualification season, with the four-division system introduced from 2028-29.

DFB president Bernd Neuendorf has acknowledged the contradiction at the centre of the debate.

“It is hardly understandable for clubs, players and fans that there are five champions but not all can achieve promotion to the 3. Liga,” he said.

For clubs such as Lok Leipzig, the proposed change cannot come quickly enough.

For Ziane, though, it may arrive too late.

The 34-year-old has now entered another season with his hometown club, still in the fourth tier despite the titles.

“Promotion with my hometown club would have been the most wonderful thing in the world for me,” he said.

“It’s a shame that we have to force ourselves to remember what we’ve achieved. It’s so hard to win this league and we did it twice in a row. You can’t take that for granted.”

Share This Article