Manchester City’s long-running financial case has reached a crucial stage following reports that an independent commission found the club guilty of 114 of the 115 charges brought against it by the Premier League.
No punishment has been announced, and City are expected to appeal, and the Premier League has also not publicly released the commission’s findings, while the club maintains that the process is still ongoing.
Man City’s 114-charge case dates back to allegations that emerged from the Football Leaks revelations, when Rui Pinto, the Portuguese whistleblower behind the leaks, obtained a large collection of confidential football documents, some of which related to Manchester City.
Documents published by Der Spiegel in 2018 brought renewed attention to City’s sponsorship arrangements and compliance with financial regulations and became part of the wider scrutiny surrounding the club.
Pinto has followed the case closely. After the reported findings on 25 September 2026, he described the decision as a “historic decision for English football” and said it vindicated documents released through Football Leaks.
Pinto also described the alleged conduct at City as “structural manipulation and financial manoeuvring”. Those are his descriptions and should not be presented as findings of the commission.
Manchester City have consistently denied wrongdoing since the Premier League brought the charges in February 2023.
Following reports of the commission’s findings, City chairman Khaldoon Al Mubarak told supporters that the club remained confident of proving its innocence and stressed that the Premier League process was not over.
“The Premier League process still has a long way to run, and our confidence and intent in proving the club’s innocence is just as strong as when this began,” Al Mubarak said.
He said the club could not disclose more about its position because of the confidentiality surrounding the case, adding that City had continued to respect the legal process.
City had previously said it possessed a “comprehensive body of irrefutable evidence” in support of its position. The club is expected to appeal the reported findings.
The Premier League has not officially published the verdict, while sanctions are yet to be determined. Possible penalties under the league’s rules include a fine, points deduction, suspension, restrictions on player registrations and, in serious circumstances, expulsion from the competition.
The case therefore remains unresolved, with the sanctions process and any appeal still to come.
Juventus provides a useful historical comparison because the Italian club faced severe sporting consequences after the Calciopoli scandal in 2006.
The case centred on contacts between club officials and refereeing authorities and allegations concerning referee appointments. Juventus were relegated to Serie B, handed a points penalty and stripped of their 2005 and 2006 Serie A titles. The relegation and title sanctions were upheld on appeal, although the points penalty was reduced.
Several leading players left Juventus, while others, including Gianluigi Buffon, Alessandro Del Piero, Pavel Nedved and David Trezeguet, remained.
Juventus won Serie B at the first attempt and returned to Serie A, but the punishment immediately changed the club’s fortunes on and off the pitch.
Del Piero, who stayed at the club, explained his decision in an August 2006 interview with La Gazzetta dello Sport.
“I listened to my heart.”
He also argued that stripping the titles could not erase what the players had achieved on the pitch, describing those achievements as something that remained with their “muscles and heart”.
The Juventus case is a lesson in the possible consequences of a major disciplinary case, rather than a direct comparison with Manchester City. Calciopoli concerned sporting integrity and referee appointments, while City’s case centres on alleged financial and regulatory breaches.
The two cases involve different allegations, evidence and legal processes.
Juventus nevertheless shows how far sporting sanctions can reach. If City are eventually given retrospective sporting penalties, questions could arise over their league positions, trophies, European qualification and other consequences.
For now, none of those outcomes has been decided.
Pep Guardiola is also part of the wider story of Man City’s 114 charges, although the proceedings are against the club, not the manager.
Guardiola was in charge for much of the period under investigation and has repeatedly addressed the case publicly.
In August 2024, he said: “We will accept, like we have always done, the verdict.”
After the Premier League announced the charges in February 2023, Guardiola similarly said:
“Just in case we are not innocent we will accept what the judge and the Premier League decides.”
Those comments do not establish that Guardiola knew about, approved or participated in any alleged wrongdoing.
His relevance to the story is that he managed City during much of the period under investigation and has been one of the club’s most prominent public defenders.
Guardiola’s response is likely to attract attention if City appeal the reported findings and the case continues.
The reported findings have raised questions about the Premier League titles City won during the period covered by the investigation.
But the position is clear for now: no Premier League title has been stripped, no replacement champion has been declared and no sporting sanction has been announced.
If retrospective sanctions are eventually imposed, clubs that finished behind City in the relevant seasons could become part of the discussion.
Manchester United, for example, finished level on points with City in 2011-12 but lost the title on goal difference. Liverpool finished two points behind City in 2013-14.
Other clubs also finished runners-up during City’s title-winning years.
Whether any of those clubs could eventually be recognised as champions would depend on the sanctions imposed and the rules governing any retrospective changes. The same applies to European qualification, prize money and other sporting consequences.
For now, those remain questions rather than decisions.
That is where Juventus becomes relevant to the Manchester City case.
The Italian club survived a punishment that affected its division, titles and playing squad. It also showed that the consequences of a major disciplinary case can extend well beyond the initial verdict.
City, however, are not facing the same allegations and cannot simply be expected to receive the same punishment.
Their case concerns alleged financial reporting breaches, sponsorship revenue, remuneration, financial regulations and cooperation with the Premier League investigation.
The reported 114 findings now shift attention to what comes next: the sanctions, any appeal and whether the final outcome will have an effect on City’s trophies or historical league positions.
Until those decisions are made, the titles remain where they are.
Jurgen Klopp has called for FIFA president, Gianni Infantino, to be replaced, saying a change…
Super Eagles forward, Moses Usor, has explained how he developed an immediate understanding with defender…
Seven-time Formula 1 world champion, Lewis Hamilton, has called on the sport to take further…
Super Eagles winger, Moses Simon is the steadiest option Eric Chelle has to replace the…
Manchester United target Fulham's Calvin Bassey and Brentford's Nathan Collins, AC Milan want Endrick on…
Super Eagles midfielder, Alex Iwobi, believes Nigeria has what it takes to overcome any opposition…
This website uses cookies.