A number of Premier League clubs want Manchester City to face both retrospective punishments and future sanctions if the club’s appeal against its financial rule breaches fails.
Recall that an independent commission found City guilty of all charges relating to breaches of the Premier League’s financial regulations between the 2009-10 and 2017-18 seasons.
City have appealed against the verdict.
However, there is understood to be a consensus among a group of Premier League executives that any sanctions should address the period in which the club breached the rules while also restricting its ability to gain an advantage in future.
At least four Premier League boardrooms are understood to believe that a single points deduction resulting in relegation to the Championship would not be sufficient given the seriousness of the findings.
There are differences among clubs over what they consider an appropriate punishment for City, who were found guilty of all the serious financial rule breaches considered by the independent commission.
One senior club source said City should be stripped of the titles they won during the period covered by the charges.
The source said there was “no great rush” to redistribute the trophies, arguing instead that the honours should be taken away and left vacant.
The source also warned that the Premier League’s credibility would be damaged if City were allowed to retain the eight major trophies they won during the period in which they were found guilty of financial breaches.
However, BBC Sport previously reported that there was little appetite among other clubs for City to be stripped of their titles.
Calls for sanctions over multiple seasons
Some club executives are concerned that a punishment covering only one season would amount to a temporary setback for City, given the likelihood of an immediate return to the Premier League if they were relegated.
A number of Premier League figures therefore believe any points deduction should be spread across several seasons.
There is also support for transfer restrictions covering multiple windows, which clubs believe could make it more difficult for City to return to the Premier League quickly.
One club source described it as “bizarre, almost obtuse” if City were allowed to conduct transfers in the January window while the case remained unresolved and sanctions had not been imposed.
Some clubs have also expressed frustration at what they regard as a lack of clarity from the Premier League over the appeal process and the expected timetable for sanctions.
However, sources said there was “empathy” and “understanding” for the league’s position because of the seriousness of the case and the ongoing legal process.
Compensation proposal
One proposal being considered is a “tariff-based system” under which City’s past league positions would be adjusted through points deductions.
A club source said the idea had “merit”, with rival clubs potentially receiving compensation based on where they would have finished after any retrospective points deductions.
City’s appeal against the commission’s findings remains ongoing.
ALSO READ: Man City: Rui Pinto to lose witness protection amid ‘life-threatening situation’
Meanwhile, City manager Enzo Maresca is expected to speak to his players collectively after they return from international duty ahead of Sunday’s Premier League match against Liverpool at Anfield.
The fixture will be City’s first since the commission’s verdict became public.
Merseyside Police said it would have an “appropriate policing operation in place on the day” after receiving queries about the match.
Liverpool sources said there would be no additional measures, with conversations and meetings between the club, supporters and relevant authorities taking place before every home game.
One source said supporters had the right to express their feelings but hoped they would not “overstep the mark”.
(BBC)
