EPL

Premier League to publish referee, VAR decisions under new transparency measures

The Premier League will publish the full judgements of its Key Match Incidents (KMI) Panel on referee and video assistant referee (VAR) decisions from the 2026/27 season as part of new measures to improve transparency.

The league will also publish selected direct quotes from referees and VARs explaining decisions and expand the use of RefCam to include audio of conversations between referees and players.

The KMI Panel has reviewed major incidents since the 2022/23 season, but its full judgements have previously remained private.

The panel assesses incidents including goals, penalties, red cards, and offside decisions, with each decision judged correct or incorrect by a simple majority.

Direct explanations from officials

Selected direct quotes from referees and VARs will be published on the Premier League Match Centre account on X, as well as the league’s website and app.

The quotes will provide the rationale behind decisions, including a referee’s explanation of a decision made on the pitch or a VAR’s reasoning for not intervening or recommending an on-field review.

Previously, the Match Centre generally published summaries of incidents rather than the officials’ direct explanations and thought processes.

ALSO READ: What fans need to know about new Premier League rules for 2026-27

The Premier League said the new approach would provide supporters with greater insight into how decisions are made.

RefCam to include audio

The use of RefCam will also be expanded this season to include selected audio between referees and players.

The audio will not be broadcast live and will not include conversations between the referee and VAR.

It will be used in one or two matches per round of fixtures, with selected incidents made available to viewers.

The Premier League and Pro Ref will continue discussions with the International Football Association Board (IFAB), football’s lawmakers, over the possibility of allowing more VAR communication to be shared publicly.

IFAB currently does not permit live broadcasts of VAR discussions.

How the KMI Panel works

The KMI Panel meets weekly to review key decisions from Premier League matches.

It consists of three former players or coaches, alongside one representative each from the Premier League and Pro Ref, the referees’ body.

The panel was introduced by Premier League clubs during the 2022/23 season to assess the performance of match officials independently of the refereeing body.

It considers decisions according to the laws of the game and the standards under which Premier League matches are expected to be officiated.

The panel first assesses the on-field referee’s decision before considering the VAR’s involvement.

Because VAR operates under the higher “clear and obvious” threshold, the panel can conclude that a referee made an incorrect decision while the VAR was right not to intervene.

The panel also considers incidents that cannot be reviewed by VAR, including missed second-yellow-card offences.

A simple majority determines whether a decision is considered correct or incorrect, with panel members also providing comments explaining their reasoning.

VAR errors fell in previous seasons

Judgements from last season, seen by BBC Sport, showed 25 VAR errors, compared with 18 in the 2024/25 campaign.

The figure was nevertheless lower than the 31 errors recorded in 2023/24 and 38 in 2022/23.

The KMI judgements are also used in determining performance-related payments to referees at the end of each season.

Match Officials Mic’d Up

Pro Ref’s Chief Refereeing Officer Howard Webb will continue to front the regular “Match Officials Mic’d Up” programme, which is available through Premier League broadcast partners.

The programme features on-field and VAR audio from selected incidents, alongside Webb’s analysis of the decisions.

The Premier League said the expanded communication measures would provide supporters with more information about decisions while discussions with IFAB over further access to VAR communications continue.

Femi Akinyemi

Recent Posts

Klopp calls for Infantino to quit as FIFA president

Jurgen Klopp has called for FIFA president, Gianni Infantino, to be replaced, saying a change…

3 days ago

AFCON qualifier: Usor eyes starting role for Super Eagles

Super Eagles forward, Moses Usor, has explained how he developed an immediate understanding with defender…

4 days ago

‘Much still to do’, Hamilton demands greater diversity in F1

Seven-time Formula 1 world champion, Lewis Hamilton, has called on the sport to take further…

4 days ago

AFCON qualifiers: Simon poised for Lookman replacement role

Super Eagles winger, Moses Simon is the steadiest option Eric Chelle has to replace the…

4 days ago

Transfers: Man United target Bassey, Collins

Manchester United target Fulham's Calvin Bassey and Brentford's Nathan Collins, AC Milan want Endrick on…

4 days ago

Super Eagles have no excuse to miss AFCON 2027 — Iwobi

Super Eagles midfielder, Alex Iwobi, believes Nigeria has what it takes to overcome any opposition…

4 days ago

This website uses cookies.