Top 10 Fantasy Premier League bargains of all time

Femi Akinyemi

When Fantasy Premier League (FPL) was launched by the Premier League in 2002, it gave football fans a new way to follow the competition by creating virtual teams from real Premier League players and earning points based on their performances.

What started as a simple fantasy game has grown into a global phenomenon, attracting millions of managers who compete each season to find the players capable of delivering the biggest returns.

Over the years, some players have stood out not only for their performances on the pitch, but also for the extraordinary value, consistency, and points they provided to FPL managers.

From £4m bargains and little-known breakout stars to established superstars who shattered scoring records, these players have become FPL icons and have left a lasting mark on the game.

ALSO READ:10 best bargain signings in Premier League history

Harry Kane

Kane’s 2014-15 breakthrough followed the classic FPL breakout story. Starting at just £5m and initially behind Emmanuel Adebayor and Roberto Soldado, Kane was not an obvious selection at the beginning of the campaign. Once he established himself, however, his ownership surged as he began scoring regularly.

By the end of the season, he had become the most-owned player in FPL, with Fantasy Football Scout recording 45% ownership, despite more than 200,000 managers selling him during the final five Gameweeks.

His late-season decline was significant: Kane scored only twice and assisted once in his final eight Gameweeks. Yet by then, his earlier production had already made him one of the defining bargains of the season.

Charlie Adam

Adam provided a different kind of bargain in 2010-11. Priced at £5m, the Blackpool midfielder became particularly valuable because he was responsible for penalties, free-kicks and corners.

He finished the campaign with 192 points and 12 goals, with only Nani scoring more points that season. His set-piece responsibilities meant that managers were not simply buying a midfielder; they were buying access to several different routes to FPL points.

Michel Vorm

Vorm became one of the standout cheap goalkeeper options in 2011-12. Swansea’s goalkeeper started at only £4m and eventually finished with 158 points and 14 clean sheets. His value was especially clear when compared with Joe Hart, who cost £3m more at the start of the season. Vorm’s appeal also came from saves: even when Swansea conceded, he could continue producing points for his owners.

Michu

Michu’s 2012-13 season was an even bigger FPL shock. The Swansea midfielder arrived as a relatively unknown player and was priced at £6.5m, but his position in the game did not accurately reflect the attacking role he played on the pitch.

He scored twice on the opening day against QPR and quickly became one of the first names managers wanted.

His early-season form was particularly strong, with 13 of his eventual 18 league goals arriving before the turn of the year. His production then slowed considerably as Swansea’s attacking form dipped between February and Easter.

He finished with 18 goals and 190 FPL points, turning an inexpensive midfielder into one of the game’s most famous one-season cult heroes.

Riyad Mahrez

Mahrez went from bargain to must-have during Leicester City’s 2015-16 title-winning season. Starting at just £5.5m, Mahrez produced 15 points against Sunderland in Gameweek 1 and reached double figures in five of his first six Gameweeks, collecting 56 points during that opening six-gameweek run.

His ownership subsequently exploded as managers moved quickly to bring him into their teams. He ultimately finished as the highest-scoring player in FPL that season with 240 points, while his price rose to £7.2m.

John Lundstram

Lundstram’s 2019-20 campaign showed how much an FPL classification can change a player’s value. The Sheffield United midfielder was listed as a £4m defender, despite playing as a box-to-box midfielder. He announced himself to the wider FPL community with a 14-point haul against Crystal Palace in Gameweek 2.

His biggest explosion came in Gameweek 11, when two goals, a clean sheet and maximum bonus points gave him 21 points against Burnley. Lundstram eventually finished with five goals, four assists, 10 clean sheets, 15 bonus points and 144 points.

His form did eventually suffer, however, as he lost his regular place in the second half of the season before returning to score on the final day.

Michail Antonio

Antonio provided one of the most explosive short-term runs in the list in 2019-20. Classified as a midfielder but used as a forward by West Ham, Antonio became particularly valuable after the Premier League restart.

He scored eight goals in seven appearances in July, including all four goals in a 4-0 victory over Norwich, a performance worth 26 FPL points.

Unlike players such as Salah and Mahrez, Antonio’s story was built around a spectacular burst of production rather than maintaining that level for an entire season.

Stuart Dallas

Dallas became another defensive cheat code in 2020-21. Starting at £4.5m, the Leeds player was classified as a defender despite frequently playing in more advanced positions under Marcelo Bielsa.

He played every minute of the campaign, scored eight goals, provided three assists and collected 12 clean sheets. His 171 points made him the highest-scoring defender that season, while no defender who had started at less than £5m had previously reached that total.

Mohamed Salah

Salah represents the other end of the FPL spectrum. Unlike Michu, Lundstram or Palmer, Salah was already an expensive premium asset, meaning managers had to sacrifice a significant part of their budget to own him. His 2024-25 campaign showed why managers continued to make that investment.

Salah finished with a record 344 FPL points, while his extraordinary consistency meant that his price was repeatedly justified by his output.

His season demonstrated that an FPL icon does not always have to be a cheap discovery; a premium player can become just as valuable when his returns consistently outweigh the cost.

Cole Palmer

Palmer’s 2023-24 season brought the bargain-to-superstar story into the modern era. Palmer began at Chelsea with a £5m FPL price and did not make his first league start until Gameweek 7.

When he finally began producing major returns, very few managers owned him. Just 63,575 managers, around 0.6% of FPL teams, had Palmer when he delivered his first double-figure haul at Burnley.

His ownership then climbed rapidly: after another 12-point return against Tottenham in Gameweek 12, his popularity increased again, eventually passing five million managers when he scored four goals against Everton for 26 points in Gameweek 33.

He finished the campaign with 244 points, 22 goals and 13 assists, and his price had risen from £5m to £10.5m by the following season.

[ruby_related total=5 layout=5]