Every sport, hockey included, comes with the assumption that there’s a strong home game advantage, and there’s strong logic and evidence behind this. When teams have the roaring hordes of local fans on their side, and they’ve not had to travel far to reach the stadium, they’ll feel motivated and fresh enough to tip the odds in their favor, even against statistically stronger opposition.
Despite this, there’s more to the home-ice advantage in an NHL context than meets the eye, and it’s much less impactful than the equivalent edge enjoyed for home games in the NBA or NFL. Understanding what impacts home-ice advantage, and why it’s so unique to hockey, is helpful if you’re a fan, so let’s explain a few key variables.
The Intricacies of the Last Change Rule
Home-ice advantage has a much more tactical edge in the NHL because of the last change rule, which means that when a stoppage in play occurs, the visiting team has to place their line on the ice first. Because of this, coaches get a chance to see which players are being put forward at a given time, and make their own choices in response to their opponent.
In theory, this is an advantage because it lets home teams present the strongest possible front to counteract whatever line the opposing side plays. However, the last change rule is only advantageous if the home team coach can call on a sufficiently deep squad. And if a visiting team has two or three balanced, high-performing lines, matching up becomes nearly impossible to exploit effectively.
Fans need to factor this in to how they approach home games, especially if they’re planning to bet on their team. Such slim advantages as this don’t often determine game outcomes, and checking out NHL odds for Canadians to see how professional analysts rate a particular matchup is better than basing wagers on false assumptions.
The Contradictions of Home Support
As mentioned earlier, most spectators assume that the home-ice advantage comes in part because players get a morale boost whenever they have a large crowd of supporters cheering them on. However, these are professional athletes, and they generally perform near-identically whether they’re at home or away.
The same isn’t true for referees, as evidenced in research into home team advantage that took place when no crowds were present. Researchers found that differences in scoring tend to stem from decision-making by officials, with home teams getting more suspensions when supporters aren’t there. In other words, referees can be swayed by the roar of the crowd and will give more favorable decisions to home team players, while being more likely to penalize visitors.
Outside of these complexities, the NHL home-ice advantage is similar to other sports in a lot of other ways. Each arena is different, and differences in ice temperature and layout can make it harder for visitors to thrive. But really, these are fringe differences that don’t always dictate game outcomes. So, it’s an interesting talking point, but not one fans should base all of their hopes on.
