October 5, 2022

Tottenham youngster who was left severely brain damaged after collapsing wins £7m in damages for club doctors’ decision

October 4, 2016
Despite scans showing that his heart was ‘unequivocally abnormal’ Radwan Hamed (main image and bottom right) was allowed to continue playing football even though the Tottenham medical team, including Dr Charlotte Cowie (top right) were aware of his condition. The player, then aged 17, collapsed during his first game as a professional for Spurs in Belgium in August 2006 and has now won £7million in damages after being left severely brain damaged.

A former Tottenham Hotspur player left severely brain damaged after the club breached its duties to him has won a damages claim of around £7m.

Despite scans showing that his heart was ‘unequivocally abnormal’ Radwan Hamed was allowed to continue playing football.

The player, then aged 17, collapsed during his first game as a professional for Spurs in Belgium in August 2006.

A High Court judge had previously ruled Tottenham breached its duties to Radwan and this morning damages believed to be in the region of £7m were ordered to be paid after a 10-year court battle.

Hamed, a gifted striker, was screened by Dr Peter Mills, the Football Association’s regional cardiologist for South East England when he signed a professional contract.

However, despite abnormalities showing on the scan, the teenager was allowed to continue playing and subsequently suffered a cardiac arrest in his first game.

Hamed’s father, Raymond, claimed his catastrophic injuries resulted from the negligence of Dr Mills and Dr Charlotte Cowie and Dr Mark Curtin, specialist sports physicians employed by Spurs.

Dr Cowie has since gone on to become medical director for the FA in a controversial appointment first revealed by Sportsmail in April.

At an earlier hearing Mr Justice Hickinbottom ruled the club was 70 per cent liable with Dr Mills 30 per cent liable.

Spurs will not be hit with a fee directly as their 70 per cent portion was incurred by sports physicians they previously employed, who have agreed to indemnify the club.

After granting a compensation order for an undisclosed figure understood to be around £7m, Mr Justice Lewis said: ‘Radwan Hamed was a promising young footballer. At the age of 17 he was playing his first professional match for Tottenham Hotspur.

‘Sadly, Radwan suffered from a heart defect and tragically suffered heart attack on the pitch. His heart stopped for many minutes and his brain was starved of oxygen. Thankfully, Radwan survived but he suffered serious injuries.

‘There is a system for scanning and screening heart defects in young footballers. Radwan was scanned and the results indicated he might have a heart defect. An earlier hearing found insufficient communication between doctors who carried out the scan and doctors at Tottenham Hotspur.

‘The compensation will need to compensate for injury and for loss of earnings. More importantly it will need to ensure his future needs are met. I would like to pay tribute to Radwan Hamed’s family.

‘His father and mother and two sisters are a caring and loving family. Mr and Mrs Hamed have cared for Radwan since his tragic injury. They have shown great love and devotion.

‘The proposed settlement provides for payment of compensation and interest. I am satisfied the proposed settlement is a fair just and appropriate settlement.

Spurs issued a statement following an earlier hearing. It read: ‘The club wholeheartedly regrets that a former employee, as adjudged, was remiss in their duties to Radwan.

‘This judgement will hopefully now secure the best treatment and care for him.’


Outside the High Court, Diane Rostron, a specialist medical solicitor for Addies Solicitors, issued the following statement on behalf of Radwan Hamed and his family.

’10 years ago, our son, Radwan then aged just 17, suffered a cardiac arrest whilst playing football for Tottenham Hotspur. Our athletic, enthusiastic, ambitious, beautiful son was no longer able to walk or talk. He was blind – he had no idea who we were. The doctors advised that recovery was highly unlikely, if not impossible.

‘Our shock, devastation and despair has never left us and never will. Tottenham’s doctor, Charlotte Cowie, knew that Radwan might have a potentially fatal cardiac condition. That vital information was never shared with us or Radwan.

‘Just as Radwan had no choice but to start his difficult journey towards recovery, we had no choice but to start the difficult journey to obtain justice.

‘We risked losing our home and faced personal financial ruin in order to pursue justice for our son. In February 2015, after nine long difficult years, the High Court found the Club, its doctors and Dr Mills negligent.

‘Whilst today’s settlement ends our painful crusade for justice for our son, it does not end his fight for recovery. That will never end.

‘He cannot live the life of a fit, young, independent man – that is his personal tragedy that can never be undone. The compensation awarded will provide for the care and support he needs for the rest of his life.

‘We were, and are, disappointed that Tottenham let our son down so badly and denied any wrongdoing for so very long. We are grateful beyond words for the recovery our son has made and continues to make.

‘We wish to thank our beautiful daughters and family for their love and support over the last decade. We are grateful to the British justice system and our experts and legal team.

‘Finally, we hope that steps will be taken to ensure that our tragedy is not repeated and inflicted upon another family.’

%d bloggers like this: